Last year I wrote a post detailing the Hall of Fame credentials of each candidate on the ballot using a system I devised called Hall of Fame Score (HOFSc). I thought it worked well but I wasn't finished tweaking. I messed around with the formula some more during the summer until I came up with something I think works better. The main difference is now performance relative to the league has more weight than just WAR.
Craig Biggio was the odds on favorite to be elected last season but he only garnered 68% of the votes (75% is necessary) and therefore was not elected. Now the ballot is gaining several other players who many feel are deserving of enshrinement including Greg Maddux, Frank Thomas, and Curt Schilling. These players plus the carryovers from last season make for one heck of a dilemma for voters. If multiple players are not elected this time around it's conceivable in the near future there will be up to twenty players who are legitimate candidates. Until the voters come to a consensus on how to treat the players who dabbled in PEDs (or those who are speculated to have done so) or until the Baseball Writers Association allows more than ten players to be selected on a ballot, we're going to have quite a mess on our hands.
Here's what the ballot looks like this time with their respective HOFSc:
Catchers - Avg/Median HOFSc = 74.00/75.15
Paul LoDuca (24.6): LoDuca had one really nice season with the Dodgers in 2001 where he batted .320/.374/.543. He never matched those lofty numbers again but managed to stick around for another decade as a decent hitting catcher.
Mike Piazza (92.40): It's a bit of a shame Piazza didn't get in last season because now the ballot is filled with other great candidates. I think he'll get in next year but not this year. My scoring system puts him fourth among catchers so there's no excuse for shutting him out for too long.